PULTEVENT
White elephant gift exchange rules, and 7 ways to run it on a big screen
A finished basement in Columbus, Ohio, the Saturday before Christmas. Twenty-two people on folding chairs in a rough horseshoe, a pile of wrapped boxes on the pool table, and one gift everybody has been eyeing for ten minutes because it is shaped exactly like a bottle. Number seven opens a heated foot massager. Number eight looks at the bottle-shaped box, looks at the foot massager, and steals the foot massager. Her brother-in-law makes a noise I can only describe as betrayal.
★ Free for the first 3 days, no card required
That noise is the whole point of a white elephant exchange. Nobody remembers who got the scented candle. They remember the steal, the groan, the third and final steal that froze the good gift for the rest of the night. The rules are simple, but half the arguments at these parties come from the group never agreeing on them out loud before the first box is opened.
So this page starts with the rules in plain words, then the house rules worth deciding in advance, then seven ways I run the exchange with a laptop and a TV or projector. The screen handles the boring parts: who goes next, how long a turn lasts, which gift wins the vote at the end. Guests who vote or draw a ticket do it from their own phones by scanning a QR code, and those phones need internet.
7 ways to run a white elephant exchange with a screen in the room
1 The classic open-or-steal, with a drawn order
Every guest who brought a gift scans the QR code and gets a ticket. Instead of pulling numbers from a hat, you press draw and the drum on the screen picks who goes first, then second, and so on. Each winner drops out of the next draw, so nobody gets two turns.
How to run it. Draw the whole order at the start and write it on a sheet by the gift table, or draw one player at a time for more suspense. The second way is slower and louder.
The order is out in the open. Nobody can accuse the host of putting their favorite cousin last, which is the best position in the game.
2 The three-steal freeze
The standard rule that stops one gift from bouncing around the room forever: once a gift has been stolen three times, it is frozen and stays with its third owner. You announce each steal count out loud and the room keeps score with you.
How to run it. Put a small sticker on the gift for every steal, and keep the rule on the splash screen caption: "Three steals and it's frozen. No stealing straight back."
It gives the exchange an ending. Without a freeze, the one good gift can hold up the game for twenty minutes.
3 The guest wheel instead of numbers
For a family room where half the guests don't have phones out, spin the guest wheel on the big screen. It fills with names from your guest list and lands on whoever opens or steals next.
How to run it. Keep a pen next to the laptop and tick off each name. If the wheel lands on someone who has already gone, spin again and make a joke of it.
A name landing on a big screen is a small moment of fame, and the wheel works for grandparents, kids and anyone whose phone is charging in the kitchen.
4 The turn timer
At an office party with forty people, the exchange can drag. A countdown on the screen gives each player sixty seconds to choose: open a new gift or steal an opened one. When it hits zero, they open whatever is closest.
How to run it. Start the timer the moment the player stands up, not when they reach the table. And tell the room in advance that the timer is strict, then keep it strict once.
It turns hesitation into comedy. The room counts the last five seconds out loud and the chooser panics, which is exactly what you want.
5 The themed swap
Same rules, but every gift has to fit a theme: something from your hometown, a book you'd read twice, the worst thing in your kitchen drawer, anything under a small spending limit. The theme and the limit go on the splash screen from the moment guests arrive.
How to run it. Send the theme with the invitation, three weeks out. A theme announced at the door produces a pile of gift cards.
Themes make the gifts talk. A jar of pickles from somebody's grandmother's town gets a better story than another mug.
6 The worst-gift vote
When all the gifts are open, the room votes from their phones. Worst gift, best gift, best steal, most creative wrapping. The bars grow on the screen and the winner of each category is shown when you close the vote.
How to run it. Run the vote anonymously. People are more honest about the gag gift from their boss when the boss can't see who voted.
It gives the gifts that nobody fought over a second life. The worst gift of the night often goes home as the proudest.
7 The exchange with a remote branch
Part of the family is three states away, or half the team works from home. They ship their gifts to the host in advance, and on the night you share the stage window in a video call. Remote players watch the drum, the timer and the vote, and they vote from their own phones.
How to run it. Assign a proxy in the room for each remote player, someone who carries out their open or steal. The proxy should be neutral. Not the brother-in-law.
Nobody sits out the loudest half hour of the party because they couldn't travel.
Turn order drawn on screen
Guests scan a QR code, get a ticket number, and a drum on the TV draws who goes next. No crumpled slips in a bowl.
A timer for slow deciders
A countdown on screen gives each player thirty or sixty seconds to open or steal. The room counts down with it.
The rules stay visible
Put the house rules on a splash screen during the exchange, so nobody can claim they didn't know about the freeze.
A vote at the end
Worst gift, best steal, most suspicious wrapping. Phones vote, bars grow on the screen.
White elephant rules, in plain words
Each guest brings one wrapped gift within an agreed spending limit and puts it on the pile. Everyone gets a number that sets the order of turns. Player one unwraps any gift from the pile, shows it to the room, and holds on to it.
From player two onwards, each person has a choice. They can unwrap a new gift from the pile, or they can steal a gift someone has already opened. If their gift is stolen, the victim immediately makes the same choice: open a new gift or steal a different opened one. They can't steal back the gift that was just taken from them in the same turn.
A gift that has been stolen three times is frozen and can't move again. The game ends when the last wrapped gift is opened. In many groups, player one then gets one final chance to swap with anyone, since they never had anything to steal at the start.
House rules to settle before the first box
Most of the grumbling I've seen at white elephant parties comes from rules nobody agreed on. Before anyone opens anything, say these out loud and put them on the screen: the spending limit, the number of steals before a gift freezes, whether a gift can be stolen back later in the game (usually yes, just not immediately), and whether player one gets the final swap.
Some groups also ban stealing from the person who just stole from you, to stop two people trading one gift back and forth. Decide, and say which.
"Can I steal the wine back?"
"Not this turn, Doug."
White elephant, Yankee swap, Dirty Santa
Same game, different names depending on where you grew up. White elephant is common across most of the US, Yankee swap turns up in New England, and Dirty Santa is the name many people in the South use. The rules shift a little from family to family, especially around the number of steals and the final swap, which is one more reason to write them down.
The name comes from the story of kings who gave rare white elephants as gifts that looked like an honor and cost a fortune to keep. In the UK the office tradition is usually Secret Santa instead, and a white elephant exchange can feel new there. Explain the steal rule twice and do one practice turn, and a British team picks it up within five minutes.
How long it takes, and how to keep it moving
Plan on one to two minutes per player once people get the hang of it, longer if the room is chatty. Twelve people take about twenty minutes. Forty people take the best part of an hour without a timer, so that is when I bring one in.
What the screen does, and what it doesn't
PULTEVENT runs the turn order, the timer, the rules on the splash screen and the vote at the end. It doesn't know which gift is which, so the steal count still lives on stickers or on a whiteboard next to the gift table. That's fine. Watching the host mark the third sticker is part of the fun.
The ticket draw and the phone vote need internet on the guests' phones. The guest wheel, the timer and the splash screen run from the laptop and need nothing from the guests. You can try all of it with the free 3-day demo, no card required. After that it is a one-time license with no subscription, and the current price is on pultevent.ru/en.
About the author
PULTEVENT was built by Ruslan Barashkin, who has hosted weddings, birthdays and office parties since 2014: over 500 events, best host of Moscow 2024 and of Saint Petersburg 2023 at the TOP 100 Awards. He made it for his own nights first. The rest is at pultevent.ru/en.
How to run a white elephant exchange with a screen
- 1
Send the spending limit, the theme if you have one, and the date three weeks before the party.
- 2
Write the house rules on a splash screen: limit, three-steal freeze, no immediate steal-back, final swap.
- 3
Connect the laptop to the TV or projector and check that guests' phones get internet in the room.
- 4
As gifts arrive, pile them on one table and ask each guest to scan the QR code for a ticket.
- 5
Draw the turn order on the drum, run the exchange with the timer, and mark every steal on the gift.
- 6
Finish with the phone vote for worst gift and best steal, then the awards on screen.
FAQ
How many times can a gift be stolen in white elephant?
Can you steal a gift back?
What happens to the first player?
Do guests need an app to draw a ticket or vote?
Can we play without phones at all?
What does the software cost?
See also
Run brighter events — with PULTEVENT
All audience interactions, a second screen and timing in one app. Guests join by QR — internet is needed for you and for them.
Start free